Erie Indemnity (ERIE) · Stock analysis

How Does Erie Indemnity Stack Up Against Its S&P 500 Industry Peers?

By Quotelinks ·

Chess, chess pieces, glass
Image from Pixabay

Evaluating Erie Indemnity Company against other large players in the Insurance Brokers industry shows clear contrasts in revenue expansion, margins, and share pricing. With a market cap of $15.10 billion and a recent closing price of $268.94 on November 19, 2026, the company operates alongside larger industry peers such as Brown & Brown, Inc. at $24.90 billion, Willis Towers Watson Public Limited Company at $30.70 billion, and Aon plc at $70.50 billion. Over the recent trailing twelve months, Erie Indemnity generated $4.12 billion in revenue, but its year-over-year revenue growth slowed to 0.3%, trailing each of these three competitors.

At the same time, Erie Indemnity maintains distinct strengths and challenges across its financial profile. It delivers a return on invested capital of 31.0%, which leads this entire peer group. However, its net margin of 14.0% sits below that of Brown & Brown, Willis Towers Watson, and Aon. Meanwhile, investors pay 26.3x trailing earnings and 28.2x forward earnings for the stock, representing the highest earnings multiples in the group, while the stock carries a 2.12% dividend yield and a beta of 0.20.

Who expands top-line revenue faster?

Brown & Brown and Willis Towers Watson lead this peer group in recent top-line expansion, leaving Erie Indemnity behind. In the trailing twelve months, Erie Indemnity posted year-over-year revenue growth of 0.3%. By comparison, Brown & Brown delivered year-over-year revenue growth of 9.7%, Willis Towers Watson generated 7.5%, and Aon reported 2.6%. Across this four-company industry comparison, Erie Indemnity recorded the lowest year-over-year revenue growth rate.

Looking beyond the trailing twelve months, Erie Indemnity has demonstrated faster expansion over a longer multi-year period. The company recorded revenue growth over three years of 12.7% per year. That historical pace supported the company as it reached $4.12 billion in trailing twelve-month revenue, produced by a workforce of 6,670 employees. However, the recent drop to 0.3% year-over-year expansion indicates that top-line momentum has cooled considerably relative to its three-year average pace.

Brown & Brown currently occupies the top position for annual sales expansion among these four firms. Its 9.7% revenue growth year-over-year comes alongside a market capitalization of $24.90 billion, positioning it as the second smallest of the three external peers. Willis Towers Watson ranks second in the group with 7.5% year-over-year growth, supporting its market cap of $30.70 billion. Both companies expanded their top line at rates well ahead of both Erie Indemnity and Aon.

Aon delivered more modest revenue growth of 2.6% year-over-year, which still placed it above Erie Indemnity. As the largest business in the peer group with a market capitalization of $70.50 billion, Aon generated positive top-line gains while Erie Indemnity stayed close to flat. Bulls would need Erie Indemnity to reaccelerate closer to its three-year pace of 12.7% per year, whereas bears can point to the current 0.3% figure as evidence of trailing peer momentum.

Who is more profitable and more efficient with capital?

Erie Indemnity generates the highest return on invested capital in the peer group, even though its operating and net profit margins sit lower than those of its peers. Erie Indemnity generated a return on invested capital of 31.0%. In comparison, Aon delivered a return on invested capital of 19.2%, Willis Towers Watson posted 15.9%, and Brown & Brown finished at 8.6%. Erie Indemnity outpaces the closest peer on this measure by a wide margin.

When examining profit margins, however, the rank order changes significantly. Erie Indemnity recorded a gross margin of 16.9%, an operating margin of 19.8%, and a net margin of 14.0%, supported by net income of $576.1 million over the trailing twelve months. Every peer produced higher profit margins across all three categories. Brown & Brown generated a gross margin of 58.8%, an operating margin of 24.0%, and a net margin of 17.9%.

Willis Towers Watson and Aon also maintain stronger profit margins than Erie Indemnity. Willis Towers Watson delivered a gross margin of 38.5%, an operating margin of 20.0%, and a net margin of 15.2%. Aon recorded the highest margins of the entire group, featuring a gross margin of 83.1%, an operating margin of 22.2%, and a net margin of 22.2%. Erie Indemnity's net margin of 14.0% remains the lowest figure among the four competitors.

Capital structure choices provide additional context for these returns and efficiency levels. Aon operates with a debt-to-equity ratio of 2.85, which is the highest in the group. Willis Towers Watson carries a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.91, while Brown & Brown maintains a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.64. Even as peers operate with these debt levels, Erie Indemnity achieved its 31.0% return on invested capital with its specific corporate structure.

Who is cheaper, and how have the shares performed?

Erie Indemnity trades at the highest earnings multiples in the peer group while trailing Willis Towers Watson in medium-term share performance. The stock trades at a trailing price-to-earnings ratio of 26.3x and a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 28.2x. In contrast, Brown & Brown trades at a trailing price-to-earnings ratio of 23.0x and a forward multiple of 15.0x. Willis Towers Watson trades at 20.4x trailing and 14.9x forward earnings, while Aon trades at 18.2x trailing and 15.9x forward earnings.

Sales and cash flow multiples present a more mixed picture across the group. Erie Indemnity trades at a price-to-sales ratio of 3.7x, identical to Brown & Brown at 3.7x. Willis Towers Watson trades at a lower price-to-sales ratio of 3.0x, whereas Aon trades at 4.0x. On cash generation, Erie Indemnity has a free cash flow yield of 3.7%, compared with 4.6% for Aon, 5.7% for Willis Towers Watson, and 6.0% for Brown & Brown.

Income investors receive a higher payout yield from Erie Indemnity than from any of the three peers. Erie Indemnity offers a dividend yield of 2.12%. By comparison, Willis Towers Watson provides a dividend yield of 1.15%, Aon offers 0.99%, and Brown & Brown pays 0.91%. Erie Indemnity's dividend yield stands as the sole payout in the group above two percent, providing income while the stock maintains a beta of 0.20.

Looking at share price changes without dividends, Willis Towers Watson has outperformed the rest of the group over both one-year and three-year periods. Willis Towers Watson shares gained 4.1% over one year and 37.4% over three years. Over one year, Erie Indemnity fell 4.8%, Brown & Brown dropped 8.8%, and Aon declined 4.6%. Over three years, Erie Indemnity dropped 1.4%, while Brown & Brown fell 0.2% and Aon rose 0.8%.

Going forward, investors can track whether Erie Indemnity can narrow the performance gap against the broader market and meet external expectations. Year to date, the stock has declined 4.0%, trailing the S&P 500, as tracked by SPY, which gained 5.8% year to date and 9.2% over one year. The shares trade between a 52-week low of $207.24 and a 52-week high of $299.78. Across Wall Street, 1 analyst covers the company with a mean price target of $115.00, which sits 57.2% below the last close of $268.94.

Figures as of November 19, 2026. For information only, not investment advice.